The New York Times asks the all-important question of whether Soylent can replace food altogether. If you don’t know what Soylent is, it’s a liquid mix of nutrients that your body needs to forego solid foods forever. One man (its founder) has already begun the Soylent-only diet and says its doable. You can sort of make it at home too and try it for yourself.

But overall, people don’t seem convinced. Especially if it takes the joys of eating out of the equation.